Eataly NYC Flatiron

Reviews

• Ross S.

  star star star star star 10 June 2026

  love this place and been shopping dining here for years.
  everything about this place and the one downtown is great, the food selection, service and verity of restaurants.
  and i would also highly suggest not to miss on the ice cream and coffee right before you leave! just awesomeness all around.

• Paul S.

  star star star star star_border 8 June 2026

  Cool little place to cheap out if you're in the area. This one is filled with various restaurants and stuff.
  
  It definitely gets hype from the tourist there, but I think it's a cool place overall to check out at least once.
  
  Workers are friendly for sure and will help however they can.

• N T.

  star star star star_border star_border 5 June 2026

  This place is way too busy! Waiters were so disorganized. I was asked if I wanted to order drinks like 3 times from 3 different waiters. I never got bread. I had to ask for bread after a second time.
  
  Also, waiters treat you differently if you don't order a lot of food or drinks. Hungry for tips huh? ??!?

• Rula S.

  star star star star star_border 30 May 2026

  I've never had a bad thing here....the only annoying factor is the 2.3 catrillion people that walk through every minute!
  
  Whenever I'm in NYC, I follow those 2.3 catrillion people to grab myself a beautiful cappuccino, gelato, or a sniff of Italy.  
  
  You can get anything Italian here-last I saw, you can even get a plane ticket to Italy. But....if you can't go there, stop here and get everything you need including fresh pasta, seafood, cheese, biscuits, bread, Jam, soaps, coffee, chocolate....just to make a few delicious items.  
  
  I love coming in here, grabbing a coffee-taking a stroll in here to see what's new, and then watching the 2.3 catrillion peeps stroll in and out.
  
  If it's warm...and oh love espresso, get the affogato, even if it's not warm, try it. It's the most delicious combination of coffee and ice cream I've ever met.  
  
  If you're a hot chocolate lover, you will never regret trying the hot cocoa here. It's decadent, thick and rich....oh la la!

• Melodie M.

  star star star star_border star_border 25 May 2026

  This place is a very cool all-things Italian store. It is a lot of fun to walk through and look at and experience. 5 stars for the atmosphere and viewing experience.
  
  5 stars for the cannoli bar. I had a Sheep's Milk cannoli (the Sicilian way!) with pistachios blended into the cannoli cream; it was insanely delicious! Just the idea of a dedicated cannoli bar blows my mind.
  
  Unfortunately, my other experience was not so great. I sat at a hightop table and ordered from a limited menu with some friends. I ordered one of 3 pasta dishes available. It was supposed to include prosciutto, which was completely missing. The only items that appeared in my bowl were pasta that looked like spaghetti, ground beef and olive oil. No sauce, no herbs, no vegetables. The bowl itself, though it was priced as an entree, was a small-medium sized bowl. I was starving and ate it, thinking that I made better pasta at home. The pasta was stuck together and clumped in more than one part of the bowl! I would have stopped to show this to my waitress but she had disappeared once again.
  
  My waitress was very busy and could not refill the water pitcher on the table, nor ever offer any of us ground cheese or pepper. The mixed drink I tried to order was no longer available. I asked where the prosciutto was, but I was just told it was in there. Somewhere, mysteriously!